Read this article in Русский

Fifty Ways to Kill Navalny

September 17, 2020

This week’s flow of disinformation demonstrates a continuation of one of the weirdest “lines of defence” for the claim that Russian authorities have nothing to explain in the case of the poisoning of Alexei Navalny, the prominent Russian dissident and anti-corruption activist: “Russia knows better ways to kill him”. Crimea-based News Front’s Spanish edition lines up a few alternatives:

A butter knife, a gun, a speeding car, a traffic accident…

Sarcasm, irony, “humour” is frequently exploited as a means of disinformation. The method was used in the Skripal case and it is used here. Some pro-Kremlin pundits, most of them residing in the West, generously offer their expertise:

It is actually surprising that we haven’t documented suggestions to drop a piano on the victim or put Navalny in a tank full of sharks. MI6, after all, is involved! We all know the tricks from the James Bond movies! Or why not an ice-pick, as in the case of late Leon Trotsky, attacked on Kremlin orders on 20 August 1940, exactly 80 years before the poisoning of Alexei Navalny.

The Russian Mission in the EU has issued a statement, suggesting that “there are questions”. In the statement, the Russian diplomats question why Russian state operatives would kill such an irrelevant figure as Navalny:

What would be the reason for the Russian authorities to poison Alexey Navalny, taking into account that his actual popularity level hardly reaches 2%?

It is hard to see how Navalny’s “popularity level” is relevant in an investigation to a violent crime. Yet the figure, referred to by the Representation, can be disputed. A survey from the Levada institute June 2020 finds Mr. Navalny as the second most inspirational figure in the Russian public sphere; incumbent president Vladimir Putin topping the list. In the age group 25 – 39, Putin and Navalny share the lead and in the age group 40 – 54, Navalny outshines Putin.

EU Expecting Investigation

The EU has been very clear that we expect the Russian Government to conduct an urgent transparent investigation in full cooperation with the OPCW. All questions should be addressed and answers given within the proper process and timeline of the investigation, not through public exchanges of “questionnaires”.

The military grade toxic substance used for attacking Navalny was detected by a German laboratory 2 September. The analysis has since been corroborated independently by laboratories in France and Sweden. As the substance used in the attack is forbidden in international law, the case has been referred by the German authorities to the Organisation for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons, OCPW.

The Deep State Goes Staat im Staate

Last week, the Disinformation Review demonstrated the similarities in the storytelling of the Skripal and the Navalny Cases. The trend continues this week. “Demonising Putin”, “Western Geopolitical Ambitions”, “The Victim’s Own Fault”, “Russophobia”… Several outlets connect the Navalny case with Nord Stream 2, hinting that the poisoning of Mr Navalny is part of an internal German political debate, where a mythical German Deep State is attacking Chancellor Angela Merkel.

The second dominating topic this week is, of course, the situation in Belarus. As in the Navalny case, most stories are based on comfortable old tropes. In the pro-Kremlin universe, protests are always organised by puppet-masters abroad. Pro-Kremlin outlets suggest a few culprits, and how to deal with those orchestrating the protests against Lukashenka:

Externally inspired protests sponsored by the EU, NATO, or even the Jews – Soros or Bernard Levy – should be “appeased” by force.

The Kremlin’s catalogue of foreign malefactors is rarely updated: Lithuania, Poland, the UK, the US… all have, in the world view of pro-Kremlin outlets, the means, the methods and the ambition to manipulate the perfectly peaceful and prosperous Belarus. The pro-Kremlin media refuses to accept the idea of the people as an active subject, and insist that outside forces have brought Belarus to the verge of civil war. So far, the only window broken during several weeks of protest was crashed by an officer of the Police in Minsk. And the Lukashenka regime has brought foreign strike-breakers and even protesters from abroad to imitate support.

Digital Fingerprints

This week also offers a chance to study a blatant piece of forgery: a fake letter from the Vice-President of the European Commission Margaritis Schinas. According to the bogus letter, the EU plans to establish camps for “Arab Migrants” in Georgia. The falsification was almost immediately intercepted and de-bunked, but a few outlets reproduced the claim nevertheless. EUvsDisinfo will return to the topic to demonstrate how the forged letter was injected in the information flow and the tracks the forgers left.

Other Notable Pieces of Disinformation this Week:

At the time of writing, Mr. Navalny has greeted his followers on Instagram from the Charité Hospital in Berlin. Meanwhile, Russian state controlled media continue attempts to suggest Western involvement in the attack on the Russian dissident.

Edits: Typos corrected


related disinfo cases

Date
Title
Outlets
Country
14.09.2020
  • nk.org.ua,
  • alternatio.org
US, Belarus, Ukraine
14.09.2020
  • RT English - YouTube
UK, Germany, US, Russia
14.09.2020
  • asd.news
Belarus, Ukraine, Russia
13.09.2020
  • nk.org.ua
UK, Russia
13.09.2020
  • Rossia 24 - YouTube
Germany, Russia
13.09.2020
  • fr.news-front.info
Ukraine, Russia
12.09.2020
  • mundo.sputniknews.com
Germany, US, Russia
12.09.2020
  • pl.sputniknews.com
Bulgaria, Belarus
11.09.2020
  • antifashist.com
US
11.09.2020
  • alahednews.com.lb,
  • albidda.net,
  • albidda.net,
  • almanar-tv.net,
  • almanar.com.lb,
  • almanartv.com.lb,
  • arabic.sputniknews.com,
  • dmcnews.org,
  • elmarada.org,
  • emeknes.com,
  • emeknes.com,
  • lomazoma.com,
  • news-sinaa.com,
  • news.albraq-news.com,
  • pressnewsnow.com,
  • sadadahie.com,
  • skay.press,
  • theworldnews.net,
  • uk-arabicnews.com,
  • uk-arabicnews.com,
  • yaf3press.net,
  • yaf3press.net
Ukraine, Russia
11.09.2020
  • iravunk.com
EU, US, Russia
11.09.2020
  • mundo.sputniknews.com
UK, Russia
11.09.2020
  • Sputnik Germany
EU, US, Ukraine, Russia
11.09.2020
  • flux.md
EU, US
11.09.2020
  • Rossia 24 - YouTube
US, Belarus, Russia
11.09.2020
  • Sputnik Germany
EU, Germany, US, Russia
11.09.2020
  • Pervyi Kanal
US, Russia
11.09.2020
  • vz.ru
Germany, US, Russia
10.09.2020
  • tsargrad.tv
Belarus, Ukraine, Russia
10.09.2020
  • vz.ru
Germany, Russia
10.09.2020
  • ru.armeniasputnik.am
UK, Poland, US, Belarus, Lithuania
10.09.2020
  • Strategic Culture Foundation
US
10.09.2020
  • 6060news.com,
  • abudhabi-news.com,
  • akhbarak.net,
  • albidda.net,
  • alderaah-news.net,
  • dmcnews.org,
  • emeknes.com,
  • eshraag.com,
  • kachaf.com,
  • lomazoma.com,
  • nabd.com,
  • news.albraq-news.com,
  • shamra.sy,
  • skay.press,
  • yaf3press.net,
  • arabic.rt.com
Germany, Russia
10.09.2020
  • iravunk.com
Georgia, Russia
09.09.2020
  • Strategic Culture Foundation
UK, Germany, Russia
09.09.2020
  • news-front.info
EU, US, Russia
09.09.2020
  • ru.armeniasputnik.am
Russia
09.09.2020
  • nahnews.org,
  • novoross.info
EU, US, Ukraine
09.09.2020
  • news-front.info
Germany, Russia
09.09.2020
  • fort-russ.com
US, Russia
08.09.2020
  • abudhabi-news.com,
  • albidda.net,
  • arabic.rt.com,
  • dmcnews.org,
  • emeknes.com,
  • headtopics.com,
  • kachaf.com,
  • kol-masr.com,
  • news-sinaa.com,
  • sahafaty.com,
  • sahafaty.net,
  • skay.press,
  • yaf3press.net
Russia
08.09.2020
  • novoross.info
Ukraine
08.09.2020
  • riafan.ru
US, Ukraine, Russia
08.09.2020
  • southfront.org
Germany, Russia
08.09.2020
  • news.am
Armenia
08.09.2020
  • news.am
Czech Republic, Poland, US, Belarus
08.09.2020
  • de.news-front.info
Germany, Russia
08.09.2020
  • pl.sputniknews.com
Germany, US, Russia
07.09.2020
  • kp.ru,
  • politnavigator.net
Belarus
07.09.2020
  • tsargrad.tv
Ukraine, Russia
07.09.2020
  • kapital-rus.ru
Ukraine, Russia
07.09.2020
  • journal-neo.org
US, Russia
07.09.2020
  • de.news-front.info
Germany, Russia
07.09.2020
  • sputnik-ossetia.ru
Georgia, US
07.09.2020
  • sputnik-abkhazia.ru,
  • sputnik-ossetia.ru,
  • sputnik-ossetia.ru
Georgian region of South Ossetia, Georgian region of Abkhazia, Georgia, Russia
07.09.2020
  • Pravda.ru ,
  • southfront.org
Russia
05.09.2020
  • armeniasputnik.am
Germany, Russia
05.09.2020
  • Geopolitica.ru - Italian,
  • paulcraigroberts.com
US
04.09.2020
  • vz.ru
US, Ukraine, Russia
03.09.2020
  • bgr.news-front.info
Bulgaria, US, Belarus, Russia
03.09.2020
  • es.news-front.info
Germany, Russia
03.09.2020
  • es.news-front.info
Germany, US, Russia
03.09.2020
  • es.news-front.info
Russia
02.09.2020
  • livenews.am
EU, France, Germany, Belarus, Russia
02.09.2020
  • Geopolitica.ru - Italian,
  • Geopolitica.ru - English,
  • Geopolitica.ru
Belarus
02.09.2020
  • Geopolitica.ru - Italian,
  • Geopolitica.ru - English,
  • Geopolitica.ru
UK
31.08.2020
  • Sputnik Azerbaijan - Russian,
  • aqreqator.az
Belarus, Russia
28.08.2020
  • arabic.rt.com,
  • nabd.com,
  • dowwar.com,
  • algeria.shafaqna.com,
  • alaan.org,
  • alaan.org,
  • Khabar Masr,
  • khabar.one,
  • newsformy.com,
  • AlAraby AlYoum,
  • almatareed.org,
  • mayadeeniraqya.com,
  • eijaz.news
US
27.08.2020
  • sputnik.by
Poland, US, Belarus, Lithuania, Russia
26.08.2020
  • sputnik.by
EU, Czech Republic, Poland, US, Belarus, Lithuania
26.08.2020
  • ryb.ru,
  • polituserforum.ru,
  • perevodika.ru,
  • newsmd.md,
  • Times.com.ua,
  • kavkaz.ws,
EU, Georgia
25.08.2020
  • Rubaltic.ru
EU, Poland, US, Belarus, Lithuania, Latvia
24.08.2020
  • sputnik.by
Poland, Belarus, Lithuania
24.08.2020
  • Berestje News
EU, US, Belarus, Ukraine
20.08.2020
  • ru.armeniasputnik.am
UK, Ukraine, Russia

Subscribe to the DISINFO REVIEW

Your weekly update on pro-Kremlin disinformation

No, thank you.