ECHR refused to punish Russia over the capture of Ukrainian sailors

Summary

The European Court of Human Rights “refused to take restrictive measures against Russia” in connection with the seizure of Ukrainian ships together with the crew in the Kerch Strait on 25 November 2018. The arguments of the Ukrainian authorities and the submissions did not convince the ECHR of the need to satisfy the stated requirements

Disproof

A misleading spin on ECHR procedures.

On 4th December, the ECHR issued an interim measure, that Russia should "ensure proper medical treatment for those imprisoned Ukrainian naval officers in need, including those who were wounded", in response to a case bought by Ukraine.

More recently, the Ukrainian side appealed to the European Court of Human Rights on February 15 2019, when it provided the ECHR with additional information on the health of three wounded sailors. Ukraine insisted that the transfer of military personnel to the Moscow "Lefortovo" SIZO was premature and called into question the provision of medical services to the wounded. Ukraine requested that the Court instruct Russia transfer the military back to medical facilities. In response, the ECHR stressed that this petition was in line with Ukraine’s petition from November 2018, and accordingly covered by the guidelines on provisional measures under Rule 39 provided by the European Court December 4, 2018. 

Moreover, the European Court of Human Rights refused the Russian Ministry of Justice applications (December 10 and 19, 2018) to cancel the interim measures and confirmed the effect of the measures under Rule 39.

 

publication/media

  • Reported in: Issue 139
  • DATE OF PUBLICATION: 22/02/2019
  • Language/target audience: Russian
  • Country: Russia, Ukraine
  • Keywords: Azov sea
  • Outlet: Interfax.ru, Ukraina.ru
see more

European Parliament accuses the Ukrainian President of using the “church split” to win the election

Experts from the European Parliament have stated that the “schism” in the Ukrainian church is directly related to the upcoming Presidential elections and the election campaign of Petro Poroshenko. The current Ukrainian president deliberately provoked a “split” and created a “non-canonical” Orthodox Church of Ukraine to gain extra votes during the Presidential race.

Disproof

This is a recurrent Kremlin narrative about religious hatred. The expert report, issued in February contains nothing that supports the claims of RT.

The report is dealing with the history of the independence of the Ukrainian church from the Russian Orthodox Church. The report stresses that the Kremlin has always controlled church issues and used branches of its church abroad as a “soft power” - to promote its own political interests. European analysts believe that the formation of the Orthodox Church of Ukraine can play a role in the Presidential elections on 31 March of this year, but the researchers stressed that the fact of obtaining the establishment of an autocephalous Ukrainian church affects the formation of the Ukrainian statehood as a whole, and not just on the eve of Presidential and Parliamentary elections.

The US military has transferred about 50 tons of gold from Syria

The US military transported about 50 tons of stolen gold from Syria. The US military received the gold from terrorists who had hidden the loot near the village of Al-Baghuz.

Disproof

Recurring pro-Kremlin narrative about the US support for terrorists presented entirely without evidence. The source quoted in this article is SANA, an official organ of the Syrian government which promotes the idea of cooperation between the US and Jihadist forces.

Read a similar story here.

Italians are the poorest citizens of the EU and Italy is the poorest EU country

Italy has suffered so much from the introduction of euro that now Italians are the poorest citizens of the EU and Italy is the poorest EU country.

Disproof

Recurring pro-Kremlin narrative demonising the EU, the Eurozone and claiming that euro is responsible for the economic downfall of many European countries.

According to IMF figures, Italy is NOT the poorest country  of EU. Italy ranks 15th in terms of per-capita GDP amongst the 28 EU countries, and 12th amongst the 19 EU countries that have adopted euro.