Disinfo: New investigation confirms that Douma's chemical attack's evidence was staged

Summary

Douma residents in Syria and dozens of White Helmets confirmed the false nature of the chemical attack of 7 April 2018. OPCW presented dubious witnesses, the autopsy of the bodies of victims of an alleged chemical attack was not made, the names of specialists cited were not given, they failed or identify the dead , nor to estimate the number of dead persons. 40 members of the White Helmets explained how they falsified the scenes for Center of the Studying of Democracy problems. This is not the first time that elements concerning special effects videos of chemical attacks in Syria appear. Thus, on February 13, the BBC’s producer in charge of Syria, Riam Dalati, said that footage shot in a hospital after the April 7, 2018 chemical attack in Douma was staged.

Disproof

No evidence given. The "study" making these allegations is a PowerPoint presentation created by the Foundation for the Study of Democracy, which the report presents as an independent organization. The Foundation is in fact a Russia-based GONGO (government-organized NGO) (p.28) and forms part of the so-called Civic Chamber, established in 2005 to simulate state engagement with civil society. Although it charges the OPCW with the "juggling of facts" and using "deceitful sources" (p. 1), the study is itself unreferenced and relies overwhelmingly on hearsay and "witness interviews" which may well have not taken place. Grigoriev's previous presentation before the UN, which used the same dubious methodology to charge the White Helmets with organ trafficking, falsely claimed that all cited interviews had been videotaped and published (p. 1), whereas the most recent omits such assurances altogether. OPCW stated in its report that in Douma in April 2018 chlorine was used. OPCW regretted that it had no access to the dead bodies, which were burnt. Background: The methodological considerations, activities and timeline are an integral part OPCW's final report on Douma. It does not leave any doubts on the detection of chlorine on Douma: "based on the levels of chlorinated organic derivatives, detected in several environmental samples gathered at the sites of alleged use of toxic chemicals, which are not naturally present in the environment, the FFM concludes that the objects from which the samples were taken at both locations had been in contact with one or more substances containing reactive chlorine" (page 3 of the report). Recurrent conspiracy narrative on staged chemical attacks in Syria and White Helmets acting as terrorists and also carrying out human organ traffics. The disinformation outlets do not specify what "40 White helmets members" told themselves how they faked chemical evidence, to the Russian investigative team, or how their identity was proven by the investigators. On the website of the Russian "Foundation of the Researches of Issues of Democracy", to which the disinformation outlets refer, the original study is not available. The tweet of BBC's producer Riam Dalati, mentioned in the claim, doesn't deny the chemical attack; "The producer was expressing his personal opinions about some of the video footage that emerged after the attack but has not claimed that the attack did not happen", the BBC spokesperson told Sputnik.

publication/media

  • Reported in: Issue 147
  • DATE OF PUBLICATION: 25/04/2019
  • Language/target audience: French, Russian
  • Country: Syria, Russia
  • Keywords: Douma, White Helmets, Chemical weapons/attack
see more

Sweden turns resort island into a military shooting range, scaring away the tourists

Sweden has decided that the Island of Gotland has a strategic function in a war with Russia – who has no plans on going to war. Now the roaring from cannons never quiet over the idyllic province and the Swedish military are scaring away the tourists. The people of Gotland are disappointed with the return of the noisy military units.

Disproof

Recurrent pro-Kremlin disinformation on Western military, encircling Russia. Similar cases here and here. Unfounded claims on discontent on Gotland with the military presence on the island and on the military impeding tourism. Sweden established a military unit on the island of Gotland in 2018, consisting of a few hundred conscripts.

The EU Parliament is a place of corruption, voting in the elections is worthless

Elections are a tool used to hide mistrust of political authorities and confidence in their own strength. Parliaments are corrupt, be it through the contributions by lobbyists or through the misguided belief that one can actually make a difference by voting in parliamentary elections. This self-deception is the cheapest corruption.Elections to the European Parliament have been held since 1979. The Parliament’s chief purpose has always been the stabilization of financial rule, the best example of which is the Euro-coup. If you cast a vote in the EU Parliament elections, you will never get it again.

Disproof

This is a recurring pro-Kremlin narrative questioning the EU institutions' legitimacy and powers and seeking to discourage voter turnout in elections.

The European Parliament is the EU's only directly-elected institution. Since 1979, it has been elected by EU voters every 5 years. The last elections were in May 2014, and the next ones are in May 2019. The European Parliament is one of the EU's two law-making bodies. It has constitutional-type and ratification powers. It passes EU laws, together with the Council of the EU, based on European Commission proposals. It has budgetary powers, scrutiny over the executive, hears citizens’ petitions, and appoints the European Ombudsman. A detailed overview of the European Parliament’s role in the European decision-making process can be consulted here.

Foreign media filmed a staged scene of another false chemical attack in Syria

Correspondents and workers of foreign media filmed a staged scene in which a family died after an alleged “chemical attack” of Syrian troops in the village of Morek, in the province of Hama, according to chief of the Russian Centre for Reconciliation in Syria.

Disproof

No evidence is provided to support the claim. Accusations of staged scenes and filming of allegedly false chemical attacks in Syria are a recurring narrative in Russian propaganda. See other examples here, here and here.