Poland excludes Russia from museum project to rewrite history

Summary

Warsaw has refused Russian offers to take part in the renovation of a World War II museum in Sobibor, under way since 2014. Three separate requests — all made by private Russian institutions — were rejected on spurious grounds and obviously for political reasons.

By doing so, Poland is trying to rewrite history and deny Russia’s role in the liberation of Poland in general, and in the history of the Sobibor camp in particular. After all, it was a Red Army officer, Aleksandr Pechersky, who organized the 1943 Sobibor uprising, one of the few successful ones in the history of the Holocaust.

Vladimir Putin was not invited to the 70th anniversary event commemorating the liberation of the Auschwitz-Birkenau camp, held in Poland in 2015.

Disproof

The story recycles the charges of "Russophobia" which Russia has levied at Poland since mid-2017, also in connection to Warsaw's alleged sidelining of Moscow from the museum project.

The project did not start in 2014, Poland did not exclude Russia from it, and no decisions concerning the engagement of foreign actors were made unilaterally.

An August 2017 statement by the Polish Culture Ministry reads that the steering committee responsible for the project (comprising Poland, Israel, Holland, and Slovakia) "took the unanimous decision to continue cooperation in its current membership [emphasis added]," which had remained unchanged since the launch of the initiative in September 2008. In a further comment on Moscow's accusations, Polish Deputy Culture Minister Jaroslaw Sellin said in September 2017: "Had Russia taken an interest in the subject in 2008 or 2009, there would be no problems now."

The report does not name the "private institutions" which allegedly met with Poland's refusals, possibly because all three are run by the Kremlin: the Russian Military Historical Society, the Victory Museum, and the suitably named State Central Museum of Contemporary Russian History.

Vladimir Putin was invited to the 2015 event in Poland but, according to Russian FM Sergey Lavrov, the invitation was insufficiently solemn and thus "did not merit a response," despite the fact that identical letters had been sent out to all heads of state. Nevertheless, a full Russian delegation was present at the event. Moscow officials were also present at the 2018 event in Sobibor, which specifically commemorated the uprising organized by Pechersky.

publication/media

  • Reported in: Issue 145
  • DATE OF PUBLICATION: 10/04/2019
  • Language/target audience: English
  • Country: Poland, Russia
  • Keywords: World War 2, Holocaust, Historical revisionism, Jews, Nazi/Fascist
  • Outlet: RT News @RT (rt.com), time 13:10
see more

Violent pro-Maduro thugs are Western media propaganda

As opposition leader Juan Guaido is preparing a US-sponsored coup in Venezuela, pro-government activists in the country are bracing for possible military intervention.

The activists — or colectivos — are demonised by the mainstream media and portrayed in the West as government-sanctioned thugs who harass the opposition with impunity. In reality, these collective-action groups help alleviate poverty in working class areas of Caracas, and have served as volunteer organizers in national elections.

If they do take up arms, it will be to defend Venezuela from potential armed intervention by the United States.

Disproof

The story advances a recurring pro-Kremlin narrative painting the Maduro regime as facing an imminent US-sponsored coup.

The colectivos are not "demonised" by the Western media. These groups have been fiercely criticised by multiple human rights organizations, including Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch, Freedom House, and the International Crisis Group (pp. 18-19).

The US is making plans for the ‘balkanization’ and fragmentation of Venezuela

The United States are planning to foment unrest and secessionism to force the territorial division of Venezuela in order to gain access to its natural resources. There are several areas as potential focus for an artificially-fuelled separatism: the Paraguaná peninsula (rich in hydrocarbons), the so-called ‘Western half-moon’ composed by the states of Zulia, Táchira and Mérida (rich in hydrocarbons, agrarian and farming products), the ‘Western triangle’ of the cities of Barquisimeto, Acarigua and Valencia (strategically decisive) and the region of Guayana (rich in minerals).

Disproof

Recurring disinformation narrative about US intervention in Venezuela's internal affairs. There is no evidence of a secessionist movement in any region of Venezuela with enough support to present a threat to the central authorities, much less that the US is making plans to promote one.

The conflict of the Pemon communities with the Venezuelan state has a long historical tradition. It is taking a political, anti-government turn, but no scholar or analyst considers it a serious challenge to the territorial integrity of Venezuela. The disinformation narrative is rooted in the fear dating to the Chavist regime about the emergence of a separatist movement in the richest regions, such as the one in the Santa Cruz province in Bolivia in the last decade, that could be exploited from abroad to destabilize the country.

Belarusian opposition, civic activists and independent journalists make kill lists for Western security bodies

Each opposition organisation, civic activists and independent media outlets in Belarus prepare kill lists, which contain information (first and last names, names of the relatives, passwords, photos, etc.) about high-ranking state officials, policemen and employees of other law-enforcement agencies, entrepreneurs, etc.  For instance, civic activists can take photos of Belarusian policemen in plain clothes at public events such as the celebration of the 101st anniversary of the Belarusian People’s Republic. These lists are likely aggregated into one database, controlled by Western security bodes.

In case of a peaceful power change in Belarus the persons in the kill lists will be subject to lustration. Law-enforcement agencies like the Ministry of Interior, the KGB and the Investigation Committee will be dissolved. The restoration of the law-enforcement apparatus will take place on the orders of Western donors. In case the power change in Belarus is not peaceful, then those on the kill lists and their relatives will be declared the enemies of the people and executed whereas their kids will  be labeled the dregs of society.

Disproof

Conspiracy theory and ungrounded claims aimed to discredit the West, democratic Belarusian opposition, civic activists and independent journalists. This disinformation message is a modification of recurring pro-Kremlin narrative about western attempts to organize a colour revolution in Belarus and to disrupt Belarus-Russia relations.