Disinfo: Repression of the yellow vests in France way more violent than demonstrations in Russia

Summary

Jean Yves Le Drian spoke of a “very worrying authoritarian drift” in Russia, as well as a “questioning of the rule of law through collective and preventive arrests”. Proposals that we had not heard from a member of the government after the preventive arrests made during the movement of the Yellow Vests or the more than 10,000 in police custody and 1,000 prison sentences handed down in less than one year.

There were lot of reports about the crackdown on these protests all over Russia. But it was much much much less violent than the repression of the Yellow Vests’ demonstrations in France. We don’t see any injuries. Almost not at all. In any case, the opposition has not shown them. We see people taken away by force with a certain firmness, it is true, but without excessive violence.

France should solve the human rights issues in its own country before condemning other countries. Everyone should sweep in front of his door before looking into the neighbour’s place.

Disproof

Recurrent narrative about the alleged double standards from Western governments and media concerning Russia.

The protests in France and Russia were addressed differently by the respective police forces. The newspaper Le Monde published a study which stated that in 8 months (from November 2018 to June 2019) 10,000 people were arrested, 3100 were condemned and 400 went to jail. By contrast in Russia, more than 10,000 people were put in custody in only 3 days (23/01 31/01 and 02/02) as counted by OVD-info.

The opinion that the police were way more violent in France than in Russia forgets to take into account important differences. The Russian demonstrators themselves were much less violent, the police presence was much bigger and demonstrators arrested on a massive scale. Therefore, the use of water canons, gas, grenades, rubber bullets were not involved.

Violence against demonstrators was indeed reported on the streets of Russia during the arrests. The most iconic is probably Margarita Yudina, a 54-year-old mother of three, who was kicked in the stomach. She accepted the apologies of the police officer who spoke to her in the hospital, in a visit covered by the media. However, the excuses do not stand up to scrutiny since the police officer pretended that the visor of his helmet was foggy and that he later learned that he hit a person and was sorry for it. On the video footage, his visor is not down and the officer clearly identifies a woman in front of him before kicking her to free the path. This type of excuse became an internet meme.

There were also reports about violent interrogations by the unit of the centre "e", although these have been dismissed.

The argument that Western diplomatic services should not express concerns about human rights issues in Russia because there are issues in their own countries, can be considered as whataboutism, but also ignores the degree and magnitude of these human right violations.

Read similar cases: In Germany people cannot demonstrate like they do freely in Russia , Reports of police brutality during Russia protests are Western propaganda, Double standards around violent protests in France, Germany and Poland, The EU criticised the elections and repression in Minsk, but in fact, the EU and its members have the same lack of democracy and repression .

publication/media

  • Reported in: Issue 230
  • DATE OF PUBLICATION: 26/01/2021
  • Outlet language(s) French
  • Country: France, Russia
  • Keywords: yellow vests, Human rights, Alexei Navalny, Protest, Democracy
see more

The Ukrainian revolution was well-planned from abroad

The Kyiv protests were well organised and completely controlled. And the murders of law enforcement officers and the “Heavenly Hundred”, with which the radicals are now rushing, and even the moment of the coup were all under the control of the curators who conceived, organised and carried out this operation.

Disproof

Recurring pro-Kremlin disinformation narrative against Ukraine, containing multiple disinformation narratives regarding the Euromaidan protests and Ukrainian statehood.

There was no coup in Ukraine seven years ago. The demonstrations which began in Kyiv in November 2013 – called "Maidan", or "Euromaidan" – were a result of the Ukrainian people's frustration with former President Yanukovych's last-minute U-turn when, after seven years of negotiation, he refused to sign the EU–Ukraine Association Agreement and halted progress towards Ukraine's closer relationship with the EU.

Russia will have to help Brussels with the vaccination because of the chaos in the EU

Russia will have to provide the Sputnik V vaccine to European countries because Western coronavirus vaccine supplies to Europe are collapsing.

Disproof

This is the recurring pro-Kremlin narrative aiming to discredit Western vaccines and promote "Sputnik V", and is entirely without evidence.

The European Commission has authorised the first COVID-19 vaccines in the European Union (EU), following European Medicines Agency (EMA) approval. EMA is liaising closely with developers of other potential COVID-19 vaccines, mobilising its own resources and cooperating with regulatory partners.

COVID-19 pandemic is a global conspiracy in the interests of the global elite

The “pandemic” that we’re talking about since the spring of 2020 is not something spontaneous. This is a pre-planned operation with the goal of worldwide restructuring in the interests of the “global elite” (“world behind the scenes”, “deep state”).

Disproof

A recurring conspiracy theory that echoes pro-Kremlin disinformation about the artificial creation of COVID-19.

There is no evidence that the coronavirus (COVID-19) was created in laboratories and that the pandemic is a part of a global hoax. COVID-19 comes from a family of viruses that includes the common cold and viruses such as SARS and MERS. Coronaviruses are known to circulate in mammals and birds, and scientists have already suggested that COVID-19 originally came from bats. One of the previous coronaviruses that caused severe acute respiratory syndrome, or SARS, spread from bats to civet cats to humans.