Disinfo: Russia suspended grain deal because all Ukrainian grain goes to Europe

Summary

The suspension of the grain deal by Russia is a consistent and logical step. Such a deal does not suit us for two reasons: first, commitments to Russia are not being fulfilled, and Russian fertilizers and grains do not have free access to international markets; second, grain sent from Ukraine ends up in European ports instead of reaching the poor in developing countries

Disproof

Recurring pro-Kremlin disinformation narrative aiming to deflect Russia’s responsibility for the growing food crisis and supply insecurity by claiming that most of Ukraine's grain ships are sent to rich European countries. This claim was neither counterbalanced nor critically challenged in the article.

This false allegation goes in line with a wider pro-Kremlin disinformation campaign aiming to blame Western countries for a global food crisis engineered by Russia as part of its unjustified aggression against Ukraine.

Russia's responsibility for the global food crisis comes as a consequence of the unprovoked and unjustified Russian invasion of Ukraine: naval blockade of Ukrainian posts, bombardment of transport infrastructure and shelling of farming regions. The Russian invasion of Ukraine has destabilised global food markets and is driving food prices up due to increased cost of production, transport and freight insurance. Russia has destroyed substantial food stocks, production, as well as processing and transport capacities in Ukraine.

As can be seen from the database of the UN Black Sea Grain Initiative, as of 23 September, out of the 203 shipments, less then half, only 92 - headed to EU countries. The majority headed for other countries like Turkey, Egypt, China, and India. Besides, this doesn’t mean that these are their final destinations, as grain will be redistributed from some of these harbours to other countries.

See also article 15. of the conclusions of the European Council of 20 and 21 October 2022 which states:

Russia, by weaponising food in its war against Ukraine, is solely responsible for the global food security crisis it has provoked. Russia’s war of aggression has triggered disruptions of agricultural production, supply chains and trade that have driven world food and fertiliser prices to unprecedented levels. The EU-Ukraine Solidarity Lanes have made possible the export of significant volumes of Ukrainian crops, agricultural products and fertilisers to the countries most in need.

See other similar disinformation narratives in our database, such as claims that EU is causing a global food shortage by keeping all the grain from Ukraine; Only 3% of Ukrainian grains end up in poor countries; the rest go to EU countries; The EU kept most of the ships with Ukrainian grain, only 2 went to developing countries.

publication/media

  • Reported in: Issue 316
  • DATE OF PUBLICATION: 01/11/2022
  • Article language(s) Arabic
  • Countries and/or Regions discussed in the disinformation: Russia, Ukraine, Europe
  • Keywords: food, War in Ukraine, Invasion of Ukraine
see more

Disinfo: Latvia, Estonia and other Western countries are causing global food shortage

Latvia, Estonia, Belgium, and the Netherlands are blocking the supply of Russian fertilizers to poor countries and are the cause for the growing global food shortage.

Disproof

Recurring disinformation narratives about food shortages.

Russia, without providing evidence, is trying to transfer responsibility for the current food crisis to Western countries. Russia's responsibility for the global food crisis comes as a consequence of the unprovoked and unjustified Russian invasion of Ukraine: naval blockade of Ukrainian posts, bombardment of transport infrastructure and shelling of farming regions. The Russian invasion of Ukraine has destabilised global food markets and is driving food prices up due to increased cost of production, transport and freight insurance. Russia has destroyed substantial food stocks, production, as well as processing and transport capacities in Ukraine.

Disinfo: Poland is preparing the seizure of "historical lands" in Western Ukraine

Poland is preparing a springboard for intervention and the seizure of "historical lands" in Western Ukraine.

Disproof

Recurring the pro-Kremlin narrative about Ukraine's lack of sovereignty and Poland's so-called intentions to appropriate Ukrainian territories.

This narrative appears periodically in the context of the aid that the USA and the EU give to Ukraine in the war with Russia. There is no evidence. Ukraine is a sovereign state, which declared its independence in 1991 and whose independence has been recognized by other states, including Poland. EU and US also respect the territorial integrity of Ukraine.

Disinfo: The Polish Home Army tried to prevent peace in the areas liberated from the Nazis

The archive documents declassified by the Russian FSB prove that the soldiers of the Polish Home Army, led by the government-in-exile in London, committed numerous murders at the end of the war in 1944-45, trying to prevent peace in the areas liberated from the Nazis.

Disproof

This message is a part of the Russian historical revisionism efforts, trying to portray the USSR as a “liberator” and a peaceful country.

The Russian FSB regularly declassifies “secret” documents trying to denigrate the Polish Home Army and other formations, who fought both against the Nazi and Soviet occupation.