Disinfo: Scholz: requests to send planes, submarines to Ukraine undermine NATO unity

Summary

Demands to supply military planes and submarines to Ukraine undermine unity among NATO members and Germany won’t take part in such debates, German Chancellor Olaf Scholz declared.

Disproof

The claim is a distortion of the actual statement of German Chancellor Olaf Scholz. He criticized what he called “public competition” among some countries over who can deliver more and better weapons to Ukraine, but not the “demands to supply military planes and submarines” or the delivery of weapons by itself. Scholz’s exact words were: "From the first day of the war our strongest characteristic lies in our cohesion. We will simply not allow a country to invade another and disrupt peace in Europe", and later: "We preserve and strengthen this cohesion by first preparing decisions confidentially - and only then communicating them […] What harms our unity is a public competition to outdo each other along the lines of: battle tanks, submarines, aircraft - who is asking for more?".

The difference is significant, as this disinformation story portrays the German Chancellor as being against further arming Ukraine under the argument that it “undermines NATO unity”, which is clearly not the case in reality. This is part of a wider disinformation campaign aiming to erode public support for Western military and financial aid to help Ukraine to defend itself against Russia’s aggression, in accordance with the UN Charter Article 51.

See other examples of similar disinformation narratives, such as claims that the US is prolonging war in Ukraine to benefit from weapons sales, that Western military aid to Ukraine only will cause more suffering, or that international support for Ukraine starts to decrease due to corruption.

Go to search

publication/media

sputniknews.lat (Archived)
  • Reported in: Issue 330
  • DATE OF PUBLICATION: 13/02/2023
  • Article language(s) Spanish
  • Countries and/or Regions discussed in the disinformation: Ukraine, Germany
  • Keywords: Invasion of Ukraine, War in Ukraine, Ukraine, NATO
*
This disinformation claim was broadcast on the date mentioned above. Due to the EU decisions  to temporarily restrict the spread and dissemination of RT, Sputnik and other instruments used to manipulate information and promote disinformation about the invasion of Ukraine inside the EU, access to the link may not work inside the EU.
see more

Disinfo: US relationship with the EU is that between hegemon and vassals

The interaction between the European Union and the United States can be characterised as the relationship between a hegemon and vassals.

The EU tried to say some time ago that it wants to be an independent player, to have sovereignty, and sovereign strategic autonomy. They were told "no need". And no one talks about strategic autonomy anymore.

The United States is pushing the European Union to fully support Ukraine. The full burden of this support (economic, financial) is on the shoulders of the European Union. This is the relationship between the hegemon and vassals.

Feb 12, 2023
Disproof

A recurring pro-Kremlin disinformation narrative about the alleged lost sovereignty of the EU and its member states (more examples). Pro-Kremlin outlets often portray European states as vassals, puppet states or colonies of the US and NATO.

The European Union was created by the European Member States, who determine the EU's Common Security and Defense Policy.

Disinfo: Russia is fighting the Nazi International

Europe knows the truth. The Europeans are Nazis supporting the Nazis. And America knows the truth. They are Nazis supporting Nazis. And we need to tell the truth, and we are now at war with the Nazi International.

Feb 12, 2023
Disproof

This is a recurring disinformation narrative from pro-Kremlin outlets accusing Ukraine and its Western partners of Nazism. This claim was made in the context of Russia's war of aggression against Ukraine.

The myth of Nazi-ruled Ukraine became a cornerstone in pro-Kremlin disinformation since the very beginning of the 2013-14 Euromaidan protests, when it was used to discredit the pro-European popular uprising in Kyiv and, subsequently, the broader pro-Western shift in Ukraine's foreign policy. Nazi ideology was banned by Ukrainian law in 2015. Far-right groups had a very limited presence during the 2014 Euromaidan demonstrations itself and even gained poor results in the 2014 presidential and parliamentary elections. In 2019, the far-right parties gained only 2.15% of the vote, far short of the 5% threshold needed to enter Parliament.

Disinfo: American officials admit that the explosions at NS1 and NS2 were their work

American officials admit that the explosions at Nord Stream 1 and Nord Stream 2 were their work. Now they even talk about it with pleasure.

The US has decided that over the past 20–30 years, Russia has been cooperating "too well" with Germany. Rather, Germany cooperates too well with Russia. That a powerful alliance has emerged based on energy resources and German technology. It began to threaten the monopoly of many American corporations. Therefore, it was necessary to destroy it somehow, literally.

Feb 12, 2023
Disproof

Pro-Kremlin disinformation narrative claiming that the US sabotaged the NS 1 and NS 2 gas pipelines and that it was a plot against Germany.

Investigative journalist, and Vietnam War-era Pulitzer Prize-winning reporter, Seymour Hersh claims that the US was behind the sabotage of the Nord Stream gas pipelines last year. In a self-published report, Hersh wrote that US Navy divers helped by Norway had planted explosives on the pipelines running under the Baltic Sea between Russia and Germany last June and detonated them three months later. A number of factcheckers have pointed to numerous flaws in Hersh's story, which has received attention from Kremlin.