Disinfo: UN Security Council held honest dialogue with Russia about Crimea

Summary

At the initiative of Russia, the UN Security Council discussed the issue of Crimea. It was an honest dialogue, the first time the UN heard honest data about Crimea. The delegation from the Crimea debunked all the fakes on the peninsula.

Disproof

Pro-Kremlin disinformation narrative about Crimea.

The article refers to “honest dialogue” during an informal meeting of the UN Security Council, however it fails to mention that during the video conference Western countries reaffirmed their commitment to reject the Russian illegal annexation of Ukrainian territories. The article also ignores the criticism of Russia's actions that were voiced.

The so-called “Arria formula” meetings are often used at the UN - these are informal negotiations that allow members of the organisation to be informed on international security issues. In the Crimean issue, Council members have used this format since March 2014. Meetings are usually organised jointly by France, the United Kingdom, the United States, and other members of the Security Council in partnership with Ukraine. On 21 May, Russia decided to convene its own conference on the situation in the temporarily occupied Crimea; however, Ukraine, the USA, Great Britain and Estonia refused to take part.

Due to the coronavirus pandemic, the meeting, initiated by Russia, was held by video conference. In addition to Russia, representatives of China, France, Belgium, Indonesia, Germany, the European Union and Czechia participated. However, most countries refuse to accept any “facts” provided by the Kremlin about the situation in Crimea, emphasising they do not recognise the illegal Russian annexation of the peninsula and continue to strongly condemn the Kremlin’s violation of international law. “We regret that Russia is calling an Arria-formula meeting in a futile attempt to legitimise the illegal annexation and we underline that Russia's action, and our participation here, cannot be interpreted as a recognition of any alteration of the status of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea and the city of Sevastopol.” The EU representative stated during the conference (01:06:36-01:11:41).

The last time issues of the occupied Crimea were discussed in the UN Security Council was in March this year, where a meeting was held on Russia's violation of human rights on the peninsula. That event was organised by the permanent missions of Belgium, Estonia, France, Germany, the UK and the USA to the UN in partnership with Ukraine. Assistant Secretary-General for Human Rights and the head of the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights in New York, Ilse Brands Kehris spoke about the flagrant violations of human rights by Russia in Crimea, which include: restrictions on freedom of speech, assembly, movement, religion, illegal call-ups of Crimeans to the Russian army, as well as the detention, abduction and murder of residents of the peninsula.

publication/media

  • Reported in: Issue 200
  • DATE OF PUBLICATION: 22/05/2020
  • Language/target audience: Russian
  • Country: EU, UK, Russia, Ukraine, US, France
  • Keywords: United Nations, security threat, War crimes, Occupation, Crimean Tatars, UN, Crimea

Disclaimer

Cases in the EUvsDisinfo database focus on messages in the international information space that are identified as providing a partial, distorted, or false depiction of reality and spread key pro-Kremlin messages. This does not necessarily imply, however, that a given outlet is linked to the Kremlin or editorially pro-Kremlin, or that it has intentionally sought to disinform. EUvsDisinfo publications do not represent an official EU position, as the information and opinions expressed are based on media reporting and analysis of the East Stratcom Task Force.

see more

The EU is not a real union because member states closed their borders

Coronavirus showed that the EU is not real union. We cannot call it a union as when corona hits a country, the other countries close their borders and leave it to deal with its affairs on its own.

Disproof

A recurring pro-Kremlin disinformation narrative about the  EU collapse as a result of the coronavirus crisis.

In the exceptional situation, many EU Member States introduced temporary border controls to slow the spread of coronavirus, which adhere to the Schengen border code. The EU Commission is ensuring that EU-wide supply chains continue to operate and that flow of goods and key services continues around the clock.

Coronavirus has destroyed the European Union

Coronavirus has destroyed the European Union. The EU only remembered about coordination now when the coronavirus crisis in Europe has already been partially overcome. The pandemic showed the union’s inability to take coordinated action and left the countries most affected by it, including Italy, alone with the terrible virus.

Disproof

Recurrent pro-Kremlin disinformation narrative that the EU is collapsing as a result of the coronavirus crisis.

Coronavirus did challenge the EU's crisis response mechanisms. However, to cushion the blow to people’s livelihoods and the economy, the European Commission has managed to adopt a comprehensive economic response to the outbreak, applied the full flexibility of the EU fiscal rules, has revised its State Aid rules and proposed to set up a €37 billion Coronavirus Response Investment Initiative to provide liquidity to small businesses and the health care sector. The EU also created the first-ever stockpile of medical equipment. Read more on EU response to the COVID-19 outbreak here and here.

Crimean Tatars in Crimea receive great support from Russia

Muslims and Crimean Tatars in Crimea receive great support from Russia. All Muslims are free to perform their religious rite, wear traditional clothes and celebrate holidays. Russia does not oppress the rights of Crimean Tatars.

Disproof

Pro-Kremlin disinformation narrative about Crimea.

Ukrainian human rights organisation Crimea SOS emphasises that in 2019, the largest number of criminal cases against the Crimean Tatars were recorded since the beginning of Crimea's occupation. The number of violations of the right to freedom of religion and the right to peaceful assembly is increasing. Russian security forces detain activists and the occupation authorities deprived Crimeans of the right to receive education in Ukrainian and Crimean Tatar. According to human rights defenders, in just one year, hundreds of illegal searches, detentions and arrests and dozens of cases for political reasons were recorded in Crimea. 70% of all Crimean prisoners for political reasons are Crimean Tatars.