The Kremlin Reads Nineteen Eighty-Four: Disinformation is Truth

September 26, 2019

Sputnik Latvia brings forward a quote by George Orwell from his novel Nineteen-Eighty-Four, commenting on the European Parliament’s resolution on the importance of European remembrance for the future of Europe: “Who controls the past, controls the future”. Sputnik’s columnist suggests that the parliamentarians have been inspired by the methods outlined in the novel’s Ministry of Truth and compare the European Parliament’s resolution with the 1936 Anti-Comintern Pact of Germany, Italy and Japan.

The Kremlin disinformation outlets are vehemently attacking the European Parliament for the resolution “allows the destructions of monuments of the fight against Fascism“; it is “a political hatchet job for Poland“; it “ignores fascism in Lithuania, Latvia and Estonia”. Russian state media actually say that the European Parliament has joined forces with Fascism.

War is Peace

Using Orwell’s Nineteen-Eighty-Four for suggesting a looming dictatorship is not terribly original, but a key element of the novel is the distant, but perpetual war between the super-states that control the world. The alliances between the powers change, but the state propaganda retains that the alliances are eternal and stable: “Oceania was at war with Eastasia. Oceania had always been at war with Eastasia”.

This model is mirrored in today’s pro-Kremlin disinformation outlets. “Russia was always at war with Nazism”. We learn, for instance, that the Soviet Union started the liberation of Nazi Occupied Poland on 17 September 1939. “Who controls the past, controls the future”.

The pro-Kremlin disinformation outlets are certainly working hard to assume control over the past. The decision to move 1980 statue in Prague to a museum from a public square has become a top story in Sputnik for several weeks, broadcasting various attacks on the Czech Republic: The statue is removed to provoke hatred against Russia. The local leadership is branded “Gauleiter“, hinting of Nazi connections to the decision. And moving the statue is called a violation of Czech international obligations. Which it isn’t.

Freedom is Slavery

This week’s Disinformation Review contains pro-Kremlin disinformation attacks in almost all possible directions: We’ve mentioned the European Parliament, Estonia, Lithuania and the Czech Republic. Poland is, of course, a target. The Kremlin’s Polonophobia shows no signs of receding – roughly one out of ten cases this week is devoted to Poland, suggesting, for instance, that it was Poland’s fault that Stalin attacked the country. Or that current Poland wants to dictate its will to EU. Ukraine and the US is also attacked; the US supporting ISIS terrorists; Ukraine applying to be a US State and generally being Nazi.

This week shows no shortage of cases of conspiracies. Some old ones, like the 9/11 false flag conspiracy, or suggesting the Rothschilds preparing an attack on Donald Trump; some not very original, suggesting the drone attack on Saudi oil facilities a false flag operation and some new ones: the EU Army might be sent suppress dissident member states, attempting to leave the Union. Most conspiracies boil down to Russophobia eventually: Foreign powers interfered in the election to the Moscow City Duma recently. The West, run by mad people, has set 2021 as the year to erase Russia from the face of the Earth.

Ignorance is Strength

The Kremlin disinformation outlets set forth on teaching the European Parliament history, ignoring historical facts, as earlier Russian/Soviet statements on the Molotov – Ribbentrop Pact:

24 December 1989, the Parliament of the USSR, the Congress of the People’s Deputies, adopted a resolution, denouncing the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact. An English translation of the full text here:

From the standpoint of law, territorial division into Soviet and German spheres of interest and other actions were in conflict with the sovereignty and independence of several third countries.

The Congress notes that during this period the relations of the USSR with Latvia, Lithuania and Estonia were regulated by a system of treaties. Pursuant to the 1920 Peace Treaties and 1926-1933 Non-Aggression Treaties, the signatories were obliged to honour each other’s sovereignty, territorial integrity and inviolability under any circumstances. The Soviet Union had assumed similar obligations to Poland and Finland.

The perestroika was an attempt to cope with Soviet Russia’s totalitarian past; searching to correct mistakes; moving forward to denouncing Imperialism and Stalinism. Democracy and human rights were supposed to replace party dictatorship and corruption; dialogue was about to replace lies and propaganda.

The Soviet parliamentarians had only recently been given the opportunity to read George Orwell’s Nineteen-Eighty-Four. The novel was forbidden to own, read or quote in Soviet Russia until 1988.

 


related disinfo cases

Date
Title
Outlets
Country
23.09.2019
  • journal-neo.org
Georgia, US
23.09.2019
  • topcor.ru,
  • tsargrad.tv
US, Russia
23.09.2019
  • lt.sputniknews.ru,
  • uz.sputniknews.ru
Russia
23.09.2019
  • rg.ru
Poland, Russia
23.09.2019
  • lv.sputniknews.ru
Germany, Lithuania, Estonia, Russia, Latvia
23.09.2019
  • mundo.sputniknews.com
Afghanistan, US, Russia
23.09.2019
  • lv.sputniknews.ru
Russia
23.09.2019
  • 5-tv.ru
USSR, Estonia, Russia
23.09.2019
  • Sputnik Estonia
Estonia
23.09.2019
  • Sputnik Estonia
Estonia
22.09.2019
  • Vesti.doc talk show @ Pervyi kanal
US, Ukraine
22.09.2019
  • Vesti.doc talk show @ Pervyi kanal
US, Ukraine
22.09.2019
  • radiovesti.ru
Ukraine
22.09.2019
  • southfront.org
USSR, Poland, Germany, Russia
22.09.2019
  • kp.ru,
  • ren.tv
USSR, Poland, Germany, Russia
21.09.2019
  • it.sputniknews.com
France, US
20.09.2019
  • orientalreview.org
Russia
20.09.2019
  • tsargrad.tv
US, Ukraine, Russia
19.09.2019
  • Ukrainskoe Dosie @ Ukraina.ru - YouTube
Ukraine, Russia
19.09.2019
  • 60 minut @Rossiya 1 - YouTube
Ukraine, Russia
19.09.2019
  • Vesti FM - YouTube
Ukraine
19.09.2019
  • 60 minut @Rossiya 1 - YouTube
US, Ukraine
19.09.2019
  • Sputnik Germany
Russia
19.09.2019
  • Pervyi Kanal
Ukraine
19.09.2019
  • rs.sputniknews.com
Germany, Russia
19.09.2019
  • Sputnik Estonia - Russian
UK
19.09.2019
  • Sputnik Estonia
Estonia
18.09.2019
  • sputnik.by
Poland, US
18.09.2019
  • sputnik.by
Hong Kong, China, UK, Russia
17.09.2019
  • Rossia 24 - YouTube
Ukraine
17.09.2019
  • fort-russ.com
Sweden
17.09.2019
  • Sputnik Germany
USSR, Poland, Germany
17.09.2019
  • sputnik.by,
  • RIA
Poland, Russia
17.09.2019
  • ross-bel.ru
Italy, Canada, UK, France, Germany, US, Russia
17.09.2019
  • russian.rt.com
US, Russia
17.09.2019
  • cz.sputniknews.com
Czech Republic, Russia
16.09.2019
  • radiovesti.ru
Russia
16.09.2019
  • ross-bel.ru
USSR, UK, US, Belarus, Ukraine, Russia
16.09.2019
  • ru.armeniasputnik.am
Russia
16.09.2019
  • kp.ru
USSR, Poland, Germany
16.09.2019
  • teleskop-by.org
Moldova, Poland, Georgia, Belarus, Ukraine, Russia
16.09.2019
  • it.sputniknews.com
Iran, Israel, Saudi Arabia, US
16.09.2019
  • it.sputniknews.com
US
15.09.2019
  • RT Germany (old)
US, Ukraine, Russia
15.09.2019
  • iz.ru
US, Ukraine, Russia
14.09.2019
  • RT Germany (old)
Russia
13.09.2019
  • Sputnik Serbia - Latin
North Macedonia, Albania, Croatia, Kosovo, Italy, Serbia, UK, Bulgaria, Montenegro, Turkey, Poland, Germany, US
13.09.2019
  • Rossia 24 - YouTube
Ukraine, Russia
13.09.2019
  • pl.sputniknews.com
Poland, US, Russia
13.09.2019
  • REN-TV
Czech Republic, Russia
13.09.2019
  • ren.tv
Czech Republic, Russia
12.09.2019
  • Sputnik Azerbaijan - Russian
USSR, Russia
12.09.2019
  • Pervyi Kanal
Germany, Russia
12.09.2019
  • pl.sputniknews.com
USSR, Poland, Germany
11.09.2019
  • Sputnik Azerbaijan - Russian
Russia
11.09.2019
  • Sputnik Germany
US
11.09.2019
  • ru.armeniasputnik.am
US
10.09.2019
  • news-front.info
Ukraine, Russia
10.09.2019
  • RT Germany - YouTube
US, Ukraine, Russia
10.09.2019
  • ru.armeniasputnik.am
France, Poland, Baltic states, Russia
08.09.2019
  • Voskresnyi vecher s Vladimirom Solovyovym - YouTube
Ukraine, Russia
06.09.2019
  • sputnik-georgia.ru
Russia
06.09.2019
  • tass.ru
USSR, Czech Republic, Russia
05.09.2019
  • teleskop-by.org
Poland, US, Belarus
05.09.2019
  • sputnik-georgia.ru
Georgia, Ukraine, Russia
05.09.2019
  • sputnik.by
UK, Poland, US
04.09.2019
  • russian.rt.com
Ukraine
03.09.2019
  • ru.armeniasputnik.am
Russia
02.09.2019
  • ru.armeniasputnik.am
USSR, Poland
02.09.2019
  • sputnik-abkhazia.ru
Syria
01.09.2019
  • ukraina.ru,
  • russian.rt.com
Poland, US, Ukraine
29.08.2019
  • Bloknot Moldova
Moldova, Russia
25.08.2019
  • rs.sputniknews.com
China, Ukraine, Russia
23.08.2019
  • ntv.ru,
  • Pravda.ru ,
  • vz.ru,
  • News Front - German,
  • 112.international,
  • nahnews.org,
  • eadaily.com,
  • nk.org.ua,
  • nation-news.ru,
  • ukraina.ru,
  • antifashist.com,
  • topwar.ru
US, Ukraine
23.07.2019
  • Geopolitica.ru
US

Subscribe to the DISINFO REVIEW

Your weekly update on pro-Kremlin disinformation

No, thank you.